Thought
Pieces
If I ask you to write about a reading I assign you, this is what I'm asking you to give me.
A thought piece is how you will respond to most of the reading I assign to you in this class. You should draft them on a document that you save somewhere on your computer, then post the thought piece to your blog.
It is important to always keep a backup copy of what you write--do not just compose on the blog.
Assignment Rationale
Personal, reflective writing plays an important role in the
creation of successful public writing. Journaling, note-taking, “mind sprints,”
freewriting, and even jotted ideas on sticky notes are spaces for a writer's
mind to wander, wonder, mull, and refine. Writing down these wanderings and
refinements allows us to return to them later.
Assignment
Description and Instructions
The thought piece is a specie of reflective writing more
“finished” than most others because it offers, instead of randomness, distilled
elaboration. This distillation requires drafting and revision (unlike a regular
free-write, which is more of a pre-draft piece); each draft develops and
sharpens your thoughts, refining ideas that were at first muffled or barely
existent. You use the drafts, that is, to write your way to focus on a
particular idea. “Idea” does not necessarily, or even usually, mean “Answer.”
Thought pieces need not know, seek, or tell “theTruth.” They need only to
convey what you think, after spending some time (and drafts) thinking, about a particular
idea or question. I will always recommend that you consider the “Questions for
Discussion and Journaling” that follow a given reading as you focus your
thought-pieces, but you are always free to write thought pieces on whatever
ideas are important to you at the moment. Thus you have both freedom to say
what you wish and the assurance that you will never be without an idea for what
to write on. Ultimately, I’m most interested in what you want to think about,
so if you focus on something different, that’s fine. Just keep it related to
what’s going on in the class.
Thought pieces are graded
partial-credit/full-credit/extra-credit, though they may receive no credit if
they are not at least a double-spaced page in length (this is the minimum level
of development of your ideas I’m looking for) or reflect no thought (a
condition generally recognized as fatal to a “thought” piece). Typically they
simply receive full credit (about 2 points apiece, for a total of 15% of course
credit). However, most of you will produce at least one that exceeds my
expectations for the assignment or otherwise reveals exceptional work on your
part.
Thought pieces are an opportunity to communicate with your
classmates and I, and a primary space for you tospeak your mind. I look forward
to reading and being made to think by your ideas.
Submission
Instructions
Post your thought piece to your blog by noon the day of
class that it is due. (For instance, I’m assigning your first reading on
Monday, and our next class is Wednesday, so please have your blog post finished
by noon on Wednesday.
by noon on Wednesday.
Portrait of a Writer
3-5 pages, double-spaced
Due Friday, January 17th, by
5 PM
Not letter-graded, just credit for doing
the assignment.
Compose on a Word Document that you save,
make whatever changes you want to make, then post your writing to your blog.
The author
you have read so far (and the ones you will read for the rest of the semester)
clearly believe that good writing takes hard work and multiple drafts, and that
many of us are hampered from being better writers by the “rules” and
misconceptions we have been taught about writing.
This is true even of very
famous people who write a lot every day. Sonia Sotomayer, who at the time this
book went to press had recently joined the United States Supreme Court, has
been widely criticized for her writing. She even criticizes herself, saying,
“Writing remains a challenge for me even today—everything I write goes through
multiple drafts—I am not a natural writer” (http://wwwpolitico.com/blogs/joshgerstein/0609/Sotomayor-writing-a-challenge-even-today.html).
Here she conflates being a “good” writer with being a “natural” writer; she
seems to believe that some people are born good writers and some people aren’t.
Her conception is that a “good” writer only has to write one draft; anyone who
has to write multiple drafts must be a “bad” writer. Even from this one short
quotation, you can see Sonya Sotomayer’s conceptions of writing are limiting
and would not hold up if closely examined by the researchers and professional
writers that you have read and will read this semester.
Use what you have read, discussed, and thought about so far to consider
the story you have to tell about yourself as a writer. How do you see yourself as a writer? Is that self-perception
helping you be the best writer you can be? The purpose of this assignment is
for you to apply what you have learned so far in this class to thinking about
why and how you write—and how you might write differently.
Brainstorming Try the following to
generate material for your assignment:
·
Go back to your blog post and re-read it. What
did you learn about yourself in the process or writing it?
·
Consider what you write and don’t write
currently.
·
Consider how you prepare—or don’t prepare—to
writ a paper.
·
Think of any kinds of writing that you enjoy,
and any kinds f writing that you dread.
·
Freewrite about the writing rules that block
you, and the writing rules that aid you.
·
Make a list of all the metaphors or similes
about writing revision that you and your friends use.
You should
spend a substantial amount of time reflecting on yourself as a writer using the
concepts and ideas that we’ve talked about so far—and any others that are
helpful. Even if some or even all of your brainstorming doesn’t end up in your
paper, the act of reflecting should be useful to you as a writer.
Planning Look
at all the notes and freewriting that you did during the brainstorming, and
consider:
·
What’s interesting here?
·
What catches your interest the most?
·
What is new and surprising to you?
Settle on a
few of these “Aha!” moments as the core of what you will write for this
assignment. For each of these core elements of your essay, brainstorm examples,
details and explanations that would help your reader understand what you are
trying to explain about yourself.
Drafting Write a three-to five- page essay in which
you describe your view of yourself as a writer, using examples and explanations
to strengthen your descriptions. As appropriate, you might refer to the author
you have read in class so far to help you explain your experiences, processes
or feelings. Conclude the essay by considering how or whether the things we
have discussed so far might change your conception of yourself as a writer, or
your writing behaviors.
Audience
Who do you imagine as the
audience for this paper? It could be anyone—just remember to make clear who the
audience is. Your teacher? A teacher in the past who had a negative or positive
impact on your writing? Yourself?
What makes it good? The purpose of this assignment is for you to
step back and consider yourself as a writer, applying what you’ve learned so
far to help you better understand why and how you write—and how you might write
differently, or perhaps even understand yourself differently as writer.
GRADED ASSIGNMENTS:
Assignment #1: Summary
Full Draft due for Peer Review: January 24th, bring to class in paper or on your computer
Due Date: January 31st, on your blog by class time
2-3 pages, double-spaced
Summarize an article from a peer reviewed journal pertains to your field (or a field you are interested in). You are encouraged to use one of the articles you already found created a citation for, if it meets the above criteria.
Parameters and Purpose
Parameters and Purpose
Keeping our class’s main question in mind (how is
writing/communication done in your chosen field or discipline?), you will find
a scholarly article from a publication related to your major and summarize it
in a 2-3 page essay.
Summaries are one of the fundamental building blocks of academic
writing. Without being able to write a good summary, you will find research
papers, analyses, and annotated bibliographies (just to name a few things)
difficult to write. To prepare for this assignment, we will discuss and
practice summarizing essays during class.
Remember: A summary of someone else’s work describes
the thesis and main points of the essay. It does not include your personal
opinion on the topic nor does it judge the merit of the composition. Most
of the summary should be an accurate restatement of the essay, and quotations,
used sparingly, should be accurate, correctly punctuated, and cited using MLA
format.
Evaluation Criteria
At a minimum, your paper needs to satisfy these criteria. However,
the grade is based not just on whether a feature is present or not, but on how
well it has been integrated into your paper. The summary should:
- identify
the thesis and main points of the document
- identify
the author and title
- include
the author's ideas or examples
- avoid
judgments about the document itself
- use
transitions to connect ideas
- paraphrase
the author's important ideas
- quote
sparingly and accurately
- avoid
errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling
____________
Ongoing assignment: Annotated Bibliography
(12 entries, including 2 visual entries)
Due: March 5
NOTE: There was deadlines on the calendar for getting parts of this done, but I removed them. As long as the entire thing is posted in one place by March 5th, You're fine.
Before you work much on this, we need to talk about developing a research question that focuses your paper, so that the sources you collect will be helpful for your paper.
You will end up with 12 citations, using the formatting most often used in your field.
For each citation you will have:
1) A brief summary of the article--maybe a paragraph long or so
2) A brief summary of how the articles fits into your research idea--how it helps you say what you want to say about how writing works in your field.
There is no length requirement, as long as you have 12 thorough entries. These are for you. If you choose well, you will save yourself a lot of time when it comes to writing your research paper.
Ongoing assignment: Annotated Bibliography
(12 entries, including 2 visual entries)
Due: March 5
NOTE: There was deadlines on the calendar for getting parts of this done, but I removed them. As long as the entire thing is posted in one place by March 5th, You're fine.
Before you work much on this, we need to talk about developing a research question that focuses your paper, so that the sources you collect will be helpful for your paper.
You will end up with 12 citations, using the formatting most often used in your field.
For each citation you will have:
1) A brief summary of the article--maybe a paragraph long or so
2) A brief summary of how the articles fits into your research idea--how it helps you say what you want to say about how writing works in your field.
There is no length requirement, as long as you have 12 thorough entries. These are for you. If you choose well, you will save yourself a lot of time when it comes to writing your research paper.
Assignment #2: Visual Rhetorical Analysis
Visual Rhetorical Analysis (3-4 pages)
Parameters and Purpose
Keeping our class’s main question in mind (how is writing/communication done in your chosen field or discipline?), you will find a piece of a visual rhetoric related to your field and analyze it in a 3-4 page essay.
The purpose of this assignment is to explain how the visual argument’s visual and written elements work together to promote its intended message. This means adequately describing the visual artifact and explaining its context. Keep in mind that the audience for this rhetorical analysis is your teacher and classmates who may not have the same knowledge level of your field as you do. The paper should also discuss who the artifact’s intended audience is and how effective its argument is. Since you are using an outside source to compose this paper, you are required to have an MLA-style works cited section.
Evaluation Criteria for the Essay
At a minimum, your paper needs to satisfy these criteria. However, the grade is based not just on whether a feature is present or not, but on how well it has been integrated into your paper. The visual rhetorical analysis should:
· orient the reader by identifying the source, its date, the target audience, and purpose
· contain a clear thesis supported by specific, concrete details
· provide sufficient description of and insightful comments about the visual argument
· use and cite secondary sources appropriately
· integrate text and visuals effectively
· avoid errors that distract reader's attention ___________________________________________________________
Assignment #3: Textual Rhetorical Analysis
Textual Rhetorical Analysis (Min. 600 words)
ASSIGNMENT OVERVIEW
Now that you’ve summarized an article from your discipline/field of interest, you’ll now look at this same article in
Now that you’ve summarized an article from your discipline/field of interest, you’ll now look at this same article in
a new way – to determine the ways
it effectively fulfills (or fails to fulfill) its purpose and connects (or
fails to connect) to its specific audience. We call this type of investigation
a rhetorical analysis.
A rhetorical analysis examines
how a text works—how its words, its structure, its ideas work to communicate
with a given audience. Because
this purpose is fairly open-ended, you’ll need to focus your analysis on
certain kinds of elements the author uses to achieve his or her purpose.
Look at the essay's component parts (the
various elements of an author's
technique) to see why they are there and how they function together as a whole).
ASSIGNMENT TASK
Your task in writing this analysis essay is actually a three-part
one:
1) Determine what an author's purpose in writing is
2) Notice what he/she is doing to accomplish that purpose
3) Evaluate how successful that author's effort
has been
See the next page for questions to help you think about your
particular article and to help your plan your analysis.
Details
To assist your readers in
understanding your analysis, be sure to:
- include a clear thesis statement and
forecasting statements to guide the readers.
- explain the context (historical
background, original audience, etc.) and its connection to the essay.
- analyze how the author’s specific
writing choices help fulfill the author’s purpose.
- use quotes or paraphrase portions of the
essay. If you write about the “example in the second paragraph, the
readers will not understand the reference.
Evaluation Criteria
The rhetorical analysis should
- focus on two or three of the strategies
used by the writer (e.g., context, substance, organization, style,
delivery, or a more defined area within one of these categories).
- analyze rather than summarize the essay
(You’ve already done a summary! This should be completely different).
- contain a well-supported thesis.
- contain paragraphs that enable readers
to follow your ideas.
- have few, if any, errors in correctness.
See the sample textual rhetorical analysis in your ISUComm
Foundation Courses Student Guide, pp. 78-79.
Questions to Help You Focus Your Rhetorical Analysis (second page)
The
following questions will help you focus your rhetorical analysis.
Context
What does selection of details tell you about the writer?
What do these details tell you about the writer's assumptions about the
knowledge and experience of the readers?
How does the author convey the purpose of the text?
Substance
What kinds of evidence—facts, statistics, anecdotes,
quotations)—does the author use? How does the selection of supporting
evidence help fulfill the purpose of the text?
How does the writer use supporting evidence or examples to appeal
to the audience? Are these appeals logical and rational? Emotional?
A combination of the two?
Organization
How does the organization of the text help fulfill its purpose?
For example, if the author puts the thesis in the concluding paragraph,
how does that strategy help persuade readers?
What cueing devices, such as transitions or headings, does the
author use to emphasize important points and to guide the reader through the
essay?
Is the information clustered/segmented in a way meaningful to
readers and compatible with purpose? Does the clustering of information
follow established patterns (e.g., classification, description, comparison,
problem/solution, others)?
Style
How does the language of the text help the text fulfill its
purpose for the readers? How do the following uses of language influence
the text?
· concrete versus abstract words
· level of technicality (Does
the writer assume readers understand certain terms, or does the writer provide
definitions of certain terms?)
· formality (e.g., highly formal,
use of slang, etc.)
How does the writer use language to establish a certain tone in
the essay? Is the tone well suited to the audience and purpose?
What kinds of sentences does the writer use? Does the
writer vary sentences for emphasis? How readable are the sentences?
Does the writer use topic sentences or forecasting statements to guide
readers? Does the writer include transitions to move smoothly from one
sentence to the next?
Delivery
Are visuals (photos, cartoons, images, drawings, charts, maps,
etc.) included in the essay. How does the inclusion or omissions of
visuals add to or detract from the essay?
Do visual cues—headings, spacing, listing—help organize the text
for the reader, or emphasize (or de-emphasize) certain points?
_________________________________________________________________________________
Assignment #4: Research Paper
Full Draft due for Peer Review: March 31st, bring paper or electronic copy to class
Due Date: April 4th, by midnight
(Minimum of 1,250 words plus a Works Cited page. The Works Cited page can be your annotated bibliography, if you used each of those sources for your research paper.)
(Minimum of 1,250 words plus a Works Cited page. The Works Cited page can be your annotated bibliography, if you used each of those sources for your research paper.)
Description
The purpose of this paper is for you to investigate how writing works in your field. Since your field is a broad one with many, many different genres of writing in it, you will have already been sifting through different kinds of writing, narrowing your focus until you come to rest on one or two aspects of how writing works in your field. For example, if you want to know what kind of writing a mechanical engineer does, you will develop a research question like, "What kinds of writing does a mechanical engineer do?" Then you will do both primary and secondary research, answering that question.
What is primary research? It is research that you do. Not in the library. Not on Google. But in real life. You are going to go find a person who does something you want to do in your discipline and interview them about how they use writing. Much of your paper will be taken up with your exciting research.
What is secondary research? It is research that others have done on the subject you are researching. A good researcher is an expert on their subject, and to be that, you need both primary and secondary research. For example, you may get wonderful information from your mechanical engineer on campus. But what if ME's on campuses on the west coast would give you completely different answers based on their context? You don't have time to ask enough ME's in enough places to get an accurate sample of how ME's use writing in their field, but others have also written on the subject, and by including what they have said in your research conversation, you have more accurate data.
The very cool part about this project is that you get to contribute knowledge to the field: you are gathering primary research and drawing conclusions based on what you discover--this is neat stuff!
What is primary research? It is research that you do. Not in the library. Not on Google. But in real life. You are going to go find a person who does something you want to do in your discipline and interview them about how they use writing. Much of your paper will be taken up with your exciting research.
What is secondary research? It is research that others have done on the subject you are researching. A good researcher is an expert on their subject, and to be that, you need both primary and secondary research. For example, you may get wonderful information from your mechanical engineer on campus. But what if ME's on campuses on the west coast would give you completely different answers based on their context? You don't have time to ask enough ME's in enough places to get an accurate sample of how ME's use writing in their field, but others have also written on the subject, and by including what they have said in your research conversation, you have more accurate data.
The very cool part about this project is that you get to contribute knowledge to the field: you are gathering primary research and drawing conclusions based on what you discover--this is neat stuff!
Planning and Drafting
We will complete several assignments leading up to this
assignment. Two of the most important will be the annotated bibliography and
the research proposal. You will receive complete guidelines for these
assignments at another time.
The annotated bibliography will be due during your conference
in my office the week before spring break.
Your research proposal will also be due during your research conference the week before spring break.
Your research proposal will also be due during your research conference the week before spring break.
A complete first draft of your research paper will be due for an in-class revision workshop on March 31st.
The second draft of this paper—the version that I will grade—will
be due on April 4th.
Using Sources
In documenting your sources you may use whatever style is used in
your field of study. (Common writing styles include MLA, APA, Chicago, etc.)
Be careful not to plagiarize. We discussed plagiarism
already, and you should understand by now what it is and how to avoid it. If
you still aren’t sure how it works, we need to talk about that before
you submit this paper. Remember, if you plagiarize in this paper, you will fail
the paper and you could even be expelled, depending on the seriousness of the
offense.
Formatting the Paper
Format the paper in whatever style students and scholars commonly
use in your field of study. (Common writing styles include MLA, APA, Chicago,
etc.)
Evaluation Criteria
For this paper, you should pull together most of the skills that
we have learned in this class, and you should probably apply the skills that
you learned in researching this topic, too. Some of these are listed below:
- follow
the guidelines in this assignment prompt
- stay
focused on your thesis
- propose
a thesis that goes beyond the idea in your sources
- include
relevant, concrete details that support your thesis
- a
logical pattern of organization
- transitions
from one idea to the next that guide your reader through your material
- language
and tone adapted to your subject, purpose, and audience.
- accurate,
well-documented use of sources, including summaries, paraphrases, and
direct quotations
- few
or no errors that distract the reader
At a minimum, your paper needs to satisfy these criteria. However,
the grade is based not just on whether a feature is present or not, but on how
well it has been integrated into your paper.
Oral Presentations of Research
Due: Week of April 7-11
Due: Week of April 7-11
Research
Paper presentations will take place April 7-11. Each presentation must include
a well-organized and professional-looking visual component (to be emailed to me
by noon on the day of your presentation) and be 3-5 minutes long. The instructor
will give you a warning when you have 30 seconds left, and after that, your
presentation will be cut off. If you
don’t reach 3 minutes, you must dance, sing or otherwise entertain the class until
the 5 minutes are up, so you might
want to practice. J
I
highly recommend that you practice this presentation at least 3 times before
you give it. This will ensure that you know when to move from one part to the
next of your visual element, and you will ensure that you meet the time
requirement.
I
also highly recommend that you use some sort of notes. These are not required,
but they can be extremely useful in helping you to remember what you were going
to be talking about.
You
will be assigned to give feedback to one other person on the days you do not
present. You will also fill out a self-assessment form that will be
confidential between you and I.
Assessment Criteria:
Delivery: How confident is the speaker?
This speaker speaks loud enough to be heard, clearly enough to be understood,
and slowly enough that I can keep up. This speaker is speaking to me somewhat
conversationally, not reading or reciting.
Assignment: Is this a presentation of the
research paper I assigned? This presentation should be focused on which
specific communication skills are key, argue for why and how they are
important, and then argue for the best way an undergraduate can develop these
skills. This presentation should include a visual element and be 5 minutes
long. This presentation should include a works cited page.
Visual: How professional and readable
is the visual element? This visual element should supplement or add to what the
speaker says – not replicate it. This visual should be engaging and interesting
without being distracting or off-topic.
Organization: How well organized is the
presentation? This presentation should have a clear opening, clear transitions
between your main points, and a clear closing (A good sign of a clear closing
is unhesitant applause).
Assignment #5: Portfolio
Due April 30th (In paper form)
Due April 30th (In paper form)
Proposal Due In conference with me April 16th
or 18th (Not turning it in but I want to see it)
Audience and purpose
Your immediate audience for your portfolio is your instructor. More importantly, however, analyzing the different parts of your portfolio is really for you—to reflect on your communication growth over the last few months more completely than you have in the small reflections you’ve done along the way. As you finish English 250 and do this more in-depth self-assessment, you will 1) compose an overall reflection for your portfolio that introduces its contents and 2) explain in individual section reflections how the artifacts you’re including show your communication abilities.
Your immediate audience for your portfolio is your instructor. More importantly, however, analyzing the different parts of your portfolio is really for you—to reflect on your communication growth over the last few months more completely than you have in the small reflections you’ve done along the way. As you finish English 250 and do this more in-depth self-assessment, you will 1) compose an overall reflection for your portfolio that introduces its contents and 2) explain in individual section reflections how the artifacts you’re including show your communication abilities.
The question we asked you to think about repeatedly in this course
has been, “How does communication work in your field?” As you revise
each of your pieces of writing ask yourself how you can make each piece more
appropriate for your field. For your reflection, talk about why you made your
major revision choices. Specifically, explain to me how you see your field
differently than you did when you wrote the first draft of each piece. What changed
your perspective?
Portfolio contents
Please submit the following in two, 2-pocket folders. You may also
post them to your blog, especially if you have videos or color photos in your
portfolio. They are due April 30th.
Notes:
· On pages
3 and 4 of this assignment sheet, you’ll find a proposal for the parts of your
portfolio that will allow you to plan your artifacts and ideas for reflection
and to share those ideas with your instructor in a proposal conference to get
feedback on your thinking:
1. Table of contents and
introductory reflection
The purpose of this opening reflection is to think back
over the semester and re-examine with new eyes the communication work you’ve
done in English 150 in order to assess your growth as a communicator using the
WOVE modes. Write your overall reflection in the form of either a letter
(addressed to your instructor), using the following questions as a guide to
help you generate ideas. (You don’t have to address all the questions and
may add information not included in the questions.)
Note: Your reflection as a letter should
include an introduction, conclusion, and examples from your work.
Communication habits/processes
· How have your composing processes
become more sophisticated since you began the course?
· How do you go about generating
initial ideas for pieces you’re composing, as well as the details and
explanation needed to develop and support those ideas?
· How do
you accommodate different audiences when you communicate? How does audience
consideration affect choice of communication mode(s)?
· How do you draft and revise your
compositions?
· How do you use others (peers,
instructor, friends, family, etc.) to assist you in making effective revisions?
· How have you improved your
editing process? What are your typical problems with mechanics and what
kind of progress have you made with these?
· Which of
your composing habits have remained the same during this semester and why?
Which have changed and why?
Communication development
· What talents or strengths do you
possess in the following areas?
o W—writing (context, substance,
organization, style, delivery)
o O—oral (interviews, large group discussions,
small group discussions, presentations, etc.)
o V—visual (Place or Artifact analysis,
brochure, etc.)
o E—electronic
(word processing, e-mail content, ethical use of the Internet and electronic
images, etc.)
·
What new discoveries have you made in these
areas?
·
In which area(s) do you wish you’d been able
to do more?
2. Revision of an assignment with reflection
For this part of the portfolio, you will revise one of your
earlier assignments (1-4). As you think about which piece to
revise, choose one that 1) allows you to focus on writing and 2) you can
easily see ways of improving.
Important: Revision here means more than editing; it
means, “re-seeing” the subject. You should include
additional material, delete parts that don’t work, reorganize the
piece, refine your opening and closing, improve your title, etc.—in other
words, you need to do a significant amount of rewriting. Importantly,
envision and specify a likely audience for your piece and think about what you
can do to facilitate their understanding of your communication.
Planning and Drafting
As you begin, look over earlier drafts of your chosen piece (and
any accompanying process materials) as well as feedback you received (both from
peers and instructor), asking yourself the following questions:
· Which
areas need the most improvement?
· Where
have I changed my mind about anything I wrote earlier, and how can I
incorporate that changed thinking?
· Where can
I offer additional development or clarification?
· What
doesn’t seem to belong?
· Can I see
a better way to arrange the ideas in my new version?
· What
other issues do I need to address to make this piece more effective?
Refer to Chapters 10 and 11, The Everyday Writer (EW) for
advice on revision, focus, and development.
The piece you submit here should clearly be more successful in
achieving its purpose and reaching its intended audience than the earlier
version.
With your new-and-improved draft include a thorough, thoughtful
reflection that gives information about the following aspects of your revision:
· Describe
additions made to the piece (written, text, visuals, source material, etc.).
Highlight a couple examples of these additions and explain their benefit.
· Describe portions you chose to
delete. Explain the benefit of those deletions.
· Explain what parts you decided
required no changes. Give a couple of examples of these and offer support
for your decision.
· If you reorganized or reformatted
elements, explain how doing so benefits the piece.
3. -OVE piece(s) with reflection
Include in this section of your portfolio, one or more examples of
your work that highlight your best efforts in oral (e.g. small-group work,
interviewing, individual presentations, group presentations), visual (e.g.
brochure or other piece with image included), and electronic (e.g. e-mail
correspondence, brochure, or other piece that relies heavily on the electronic)
communication.
In your reflection for this section, discuss
the following:
· Why you
chose this/these piece(s) as evidence of your best work in the oral, visual,
and electronic modes
· What, if
any, changes you made to the original versions, why, and to what benefit
· What you
believe the piece/s demonstrate about you as an oral, visual, and electronic
communicator
Portfolio Evaluation Criteria
· The portfolio includes all
required components (see above).
· The reflective pieces
(introductory letter/essay, individual section reflections, and closing
letter/essay) accomplish the following:
o Include specific references to prior work
(examples) to support your discussion
o Demonstrate a thoughtful, honest, thorough
and coherent analysis of your progress
· The written revision (Pocket 2)
better satisfies the criteria of the original assignment:
o Substance: demonstrates a thorough
rethinking of the subject
o Context: contains additional
material appropriate for audience and purpose
o Organization:
achieves improved focus, structure, and coherence
· Other OVE piece/s (Pocket 3)
demonstrate/s competence in these modes
· Revision and reflection avoid
errors distracting to the reader
Portfolio
proposal
Purpose of chart and planning questions
- To
sketch out the contents of your final portfolio, plan what you will be
doing with each of your presentation pieces, and begin to consider what
you can meaningfully say about them
- To
discuss your proposal with your instructor and get feedback on your plans
Planning the contents
In the space below, jot down your thinking about the pieces you’re
planning to present for grading in your portfolio
In your portfolio you need to revise two of your pieces of work:
1.
Represents your best written abilities
2.
A piece that represents your best work in the
oral/visual/electronic modes
Thinking of what to say about the contents
Now that you’ve tentatively chosen some pieces to present in your
portfolio, in the space below, sketch out ideas you have at this point for
reflecting on these pieces (e.g. what your chosen pieces show about context,
substance, organization, style, and/or delivery; what their strengths are,
their weaknesses; what strategies they try to use; etc.)
Ideas you have for reflecting on your revised written piece
Ideas you have for reflecting on piece(s) contained in your OVE
section
Posing questions about your plan/proposal
Note in this space, the questions you want to ask your instructor
about your plans or any other aspect of the portfolio during your proposal
conference:
Evaluating your proposal
· Does it show
careful thought?
· Is it
complete?
· Is it
specific?
· Does it
give you meaningful ideas to discuss with your instructor?
No comments:
Post a Comment